Custard Pie Not Setting – 3 Ways To Deal With This

custard pie not setting
  • Save
custard pie not setting

A custard pie is a common recipe that consists of a custard mixture that is added to any form of uncooked crust after which it is baked. Most custard pies are made using a mix of milk, sugar, vanilla extract, pie crust, and eggs.  

Custard Pie Not Setting

While on their first attempt at making a custard pie, we have often seen users complain about their custard pie not setting. Even though this can happen due to plenty of different reasons, these users still end up getting confused about what could have possibly gone wrong.  

In situations like these, it is best that to revise the approach that you took in cooking the dessert. However, if you are having a hard time understanding why your custard pie is not set at all, then here are a few things to keep in mind: 

1. Temperature 

The temperature is one of the key elements that you will have to keep your eyes on whenever you are attempting to bake a custard pie. In case you pick a temperature that is too high or too low, it can potentially end up completely ruining your pie. 

This is why you must always keep the temperature in check. Most recipes follow anywhere around 325-350F degrees. You might also see certain recipes go up to 375F degrees which seems to be the highest temperature for baking a custard pie.  

2. Cooking Time 

Once you have the temperature in check, the second most important thing that you will have to check is the actual cooking time. You have to make sure that you find the exact sweet spot for the pie to cook itself.  

Ensure that you don’t pull out the pie too soon or too late. Either way, you will end up ruining your pie. While different recipes might require slightly different cooking times, the most ideal spot is around 35-45 minutes. Also, do keep in mind that the time for which you decide to cook your pie heavily depends on the temperature at which you are cooking it. So, make sure you have both of them in check. 

3. Ingredients 

If you are sure you are following the correct recipe, this might as well be the least likely scenario. However, it is still possible that you might have messed up an ingredient or two due to which the pie is not able to set. If that is the case, then you will have to double-check all the ingredients and their quantity.  

The Bottom Line

Oftentimes, beginners end up messing up while making a recipe for the first time. Similarly, custard pie not setting is one of these common issues that can occur due to various reasons. To learn more, be sure to refer to the article above.  

  • Save
Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap