Ice packs are widely used in cooler to maintain a low temperature, which is important to keep the perishable items at the right temperature. The ice packs are reusable and can be found in different sizes and designs, so you can purchase them according to the cooler’s size.
Yeti Ice pack and Arctic Ice pack are the two most commonly used products, which is why we are sharing the in-depth comparison to help you make the right choice!
Yeti Ice Pack vs Arctic Ice Pack
Comparison Table
| Features | Yeti Ice Pack | Arctic Ice Pack |
|---|---|---|
| Available sizes | 1, 2, and 4 pounds | .75lb, 1.5lb, 2.5lb, 5lb, and 10lb |
| Freezing time | Six hours or less | Eight to ten hours |
| Freezing temperature | -2 degrees Celsius | 1 degree Celsius |
| Warranty | Five years | Limited lifetime warranty |
| Ice retention period | Twelve to sixteen hours | Over twelve hours |
| Gel | Phase-change and food-grade | Phase-change |
Yeti Ice Pack
Yeti ice pack is one of the most popular options and lowers the internal temperature of the cooler pretty quickly. The ice pack is available in multiple sizes, but a two-pound size is commonly used. It offers twelve to sixteen hours of ice retention.
However, it’s recommended that you use multiple ice packs in a cooler because if there is no ice, the ice pack exhausts itself quickly. This is a reusable product and can be used for years, so you can save on the ice.
Construction
This ice pack is available in three sizes, including one, two, and four pounds. However, the two-pound version is commonly used as it can fit in a small cooler or a lunch box. The two-pound ice pack is the size of a six-pack, so it’s enough to chill six beverage cans at a time.
The ice pack is made from thick and durable plastic, which promises resistance to breakage. The ice pack can withstand intense impacts and drops. In addition, the gel doesn’t leak, even if the ice pack falls on the ground.
It can be frozen within six hours since it has a custom shape. These are reusable packs and can be frozen multiple times without any shape loss or cracking. The liquid in the pack is a phase-change and food-grade liquid that’s designed to freeze at around -2 degrees Celsius.
There is a hole in the middle which exposes it to cold air in the freezer, promising faster freezing and can be used as a handle for easier removal from the cooler.
Performance
In most cases, the ice packs are used in combination with ice, but the Yeti ice pack can be used on its own. It has the capacity to keep the food cold for over twelve to sixteen hours on its own, and after that, it starts to thaw.
Moreover, it doesn’t leave water puddles on the bottom of the cooler. Also, there is no condensation because it doesn’t sweat. The ice packs are designed with a five-year warranty, which means you can get a free replacement.
Arctic Ice Pack
The Arctic ice pack is available in various colors and sizes. It is designed to prolong ice retention by twelve hours and is one of the most affordable choices.
It can maintain a lower temperature longer than the blue gel products and is made of phase-change gel. It’s a biodegradable, reusable, and non-toxic item. It can freeze at 1 degree Celsius and can maintain a freezing temperature for hours.
Construction
The Arctic ice pack is a reusable option and has a biodegradable design, making it safe for the environment. The ice pack is integrated with a phase-change material that freezes to keep the food and beverages cold in the cooler.
In addition, the ice pack is made from recycled yet highly durable plastic, which means it won’t leak or break down. The ice pack is dishwasher-safe, but the heat might cause damage to the internal gel, which is why hand-washing is recommended.
Also, the ice pack is available in various colors and takes eight to ten hours for re-freezing, which can be an issue for some people.
Performance
Arctic ice packs are designed to hold a pre-defined and constant temperature of over 5 degrees Fahrenheit until the cooler pack thaws.
The ice pack is designed with an ultra-sonic spin-welded cap, which prevents the chances of leaks, and you get a lifetime warranty. According to the company, the ice packs can be used over 10,000 times without any damage or leak.
When put in the cooler without extra ice, it can keep the food and beverages cold for twelve hours but starts thawing after that. Fortunately, it doesn’t sweat, so the food isn’t exposed to condensation.
Final Verdict
Both Arctic and Yeti ice packs are amazing, but Arctic ice packs need more time to re-freeze. In addition, the ice retention period is also limited, which is why we recommend using Yeti ice packs.
The Yeti ice packs can stay frozen for 12 to 14 hours, while Arctic ice packs thaw out within 12 hours. Honestly, Yeti ice packs are more expensive as compared to Arctic ice packs, but they provide higher value as well.
