Rye whiskey was quite popular in America although, this changed when it was prohibited. Talking about this, the reputation for this type of whiskey has started to increase again now that many companies are coming out with their variations. Both large and small distilleries are now releasing new versions of Rye whiskey which have their unique tastes. These are also available in most liquor stores in America.
While the percentage of rye and malt can vary from bottle to bottle. The general rule of thumb in America is that these whiskies should have at least 51% of rye when compared to malt or corn. Many famous brands have these available, however, two of the most recommended ones are either Old Overholt or Rittenhouse. If you are confused about the differences between these two. Then going through this article should help you out as we will be providing you with a comparison.
Old Overholt vs Rittenhouse
Old Overholt
Old Overholt was founded back in 1810, in Pennsylvania. The brand of whiskey is said to be the oldest one that was continually maintained. This is a type of rye whiskey that is available in most liquor stores in America. Considering this, you should easily be able to find a bottle of it. Most bottles are usually aged for three years at an alcohol percentage of 40%. But in the late 2017s a Bottled in Bond again 4 years was released. Getting to the whiskey’s scent and how it tastes.
You should be able to smell vanilla and caramel paired with a citrusy orange base. A little hint of rye spice and oak is also present but this is almost distinguishable from all the sweet aroma. You will notice that the scent of this rye whiskey can be a bit expressive considering it is only 80 proof. Old Overholt is extremely watery and think and its flavors can be hard to pick out because of all the dilution. However, you will still be able to taste the slight traces of orange, cinnamon, and leather.
As for the after taste, you will get a ramp in all the flavors from before again but this should last a few seconds. Aside from this, you will notice that whiskey is used in most bars as a mixing agent. Although, this can be a little annoying because there is nothing special about it. This is quite obvious when you take its 40% alcohol content into consideration. Whatever the case might be, Old Overholt is an easy-to-drink whiskey because of its watery composition but it can be too bland for most people.
Rittenhouse
Rittenhouse is another famous rye whiskey that is widely available in America. The first thing that you will notice about it is the 100-proof rating on it. This means that the bottle contains a 50% alcohol content when compared to Old Overholt’s 80-proof rating. This means that the taste on this rye will be much more concentrated and stronger. The main selling point for both of these rye whiskies is their price. This is because even the 50% alcohol content can leave most enthusiasts desiring for more.
Although, you should note that both of these whiskies are extremely cheap. However, due to Rittenhouse having a higher demand, its price has started to grow recently. The whiskey has a spicy taste that is paired up with woody notes from the barrels this is made. Aside from this, you should also be able to notice vanilla, caramel, and cocoa taste. Rittenhouse is also much better when you use it in cocktails.
Considering this, if you are confused between these two then Old Overholt should most likely be your second option. The only reason why someone would go for it instead of Rittenhouse can be if they enjoy a smoother or lighter taste. Alternatively, if you are worried about the price being higher. However, when it comes to choosing between these two, spending a little more will be worth it. If you are still confused then you can also try purchasing both of these bottles and try them out. They are quite cheap and widely available so you should not have much trouble getting them.